Presidents’ Alliance submits Statement to the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Border Security and Immigration in support of international students

“Student Visa Integrity: Protecting Educational Opportunity and National Security”


Senate Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on Border Security and Immigration


June 6, 2018

Statement of the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration


The Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration is a non-partisan alliance of
currently more than 365 college and university presidents and chancellors, representing public
and private institutions from across the nation. We are dedicated to increasing public
understanding of how immigration policies and practices impact our students, campuses, and
communities and to supporting policies that create welcoming environments for Dreamer, other
immigrant, and international students on our campuses. We are writing today to express our
support for policies that emphasize the importance of continuing to welcome international
students to our campuses in order to protect our long-term national security, economic, and
academic interests.


We were pleased that the Subcommittee’s June 6th hearing entitled, “Student Visa Integrity:
Protecting Educational Opportunity and National Security,” drew a clear distinction between
those few individuals who would seek to pose threats to these interests and the vast majority of
international students and scholars who come to our higher education institutions to learn,
conduct research, and contribute to American innovation. U.S. colleges and universities excel
because we can attract talent from everywhere. Our campuses are dedicated to attracting,
educating, and graduating students from all backgrounds and places, and our institutions can
attest to the vital contributions of our international students and scholars on our campuses and in
our communities.


In our June 12, 2018 letter to Members of the Senate and House with regard to DACA and other
immigration measures, we noted that our educational institutions are committed to educating
anyone with the talent and drive to learn and to contribute to making the world a better place –
whether a native born, immigrant or an international student. In addition to advocating for a
permanent solution for Dreamers, we urge rejecting policy proposals that will make U.S. higher
education institutions less desirable for international students:


“U.S. institutions’ ability to attract the most talented students and scholars in the world –
students whose work helps sustain our academic pre-eminence and who often remain to continue
their research or to found or help lead America’s most innovative companies – is not
foreordained. It is a competitive advantage that benefits our nation today, but that can be lost to
competitor countries and institutions that offer more favorable immigration policies and are
eager to build their academic and research prowess and fuel their innovation economies.”


We appreciated that the June 6th hearing highlighted this important concern. Senator Cornyn’s
opening remarks stated that the American higher education system is considered the “Crown
Jewels” of what the United States has to offer the world and is vital to diplomatic efforts. He
went on to say, “I am not interested in restricting student visas…I have long been an advocate for
expanding H-1B visas and other visas for foreign students.” Senator Durbin highlighted
sobering statistics, noting, “We’ve seen new international student enrollment drop by 3% this
year across U.S. higher education institutions, and that number is expected to double next year,
while other countries are seeing double-digit increases.”


Additionally, as Jill Welch, Deputy Executive Director for Public Policy at NAFSA, testified
before the Subcommittee: “our academic institutions and our economy depend on the presence of
international students and scholars to create jobs, drive innovation and research, and broaden the
perspectives of American students (p. 10 of Welch’s statement, June 6, 2018).” Higher education
institutions across the country have benefited intellectually, economically, and socially from the
presence of international students and scholars, and they in turn often serve as America’s best
ambassadors and allies.


We urge careful study of existing security protocols and procedures and awareness of the global
competition for talent to avoid overly broad action that would jeopardize these valuable national
assets and encourage the Subcommittee to partner with higher education to ensure appropriate
coordination. We offer our assistance in these vital objectives and are happy to work with you to
continue to develop and refine sensible and secure practices.


Download the statement